The Best Would You Rather Holiday Questions

Last Updated on March 11, 2022 by Michele Tripple

This post contains affiliate links. If you click and buy we may make a commission, at no additional charge to you. Please see our disclosure for more details.

These would you rather holiday questions are going to be the hit this year! With 100 fun questions, there are sure to be some really interesting conversations!

featured image: Would You Rather Holiday Questions on a red border

Would You Rather Holiday Questions

It’s no secret that we are huge fans of Would You Rather! Our Would You Rather Christmas Questions and our Would You Rather Thanksgiving Questions are some of your favorites! So we thought it was time to create Would You Rather Holiday questions to add to the fun! These are fun a little quirky and are the perfect conversation starters! So dive in and discover your favorite would you rather holiday questions.

How to Play Would You Rather- Holiday

It is easy to play our would you rather holiday edition.

  1. First, you will want to download and print out our world you rather holiday questions.
  2. Next, decide who is going to read the questions. You can take turns doing this as well.
  3. Read the question and everyone has to decide which they would rather do. For a smaller group, you can go around the room and ask everyone which they choose, for a larger group they can raise their hand based on their preference.

This game is perfect to use at holiday parties, classroom parties, on road trips, at family gatherings, and more! The possibilities are endless!

pin image: would you rather holiday questions

The Best Holiday Would You Rather Questions

Join our VIP club at the bottom of this post to grab a sample or grab the complete version now!

  1. Would you rather be at home on Christmas and get lots of presents or go to Disneyland for Christmas but not get any presents?
Would You Rather Holiday Question: Would you rather be at home on Christmas and get lots of presents or go to Disneyland for Christmas but not get any presents? on a red background
  1. Would you rather have a Christmas vacation or summer vacation?
  2. Would you rather be one of Santa’s elves or be one of Santa’s reindeer?
  3. Would you rather sing the correct lyrics (Jingle Bells) or the funny version (Batman smells)?
  4. Would you rather see The Nutcracker or dance in The Nutcracker?
  5. Would you rather open presents on Christmas Eve or Christmas morning?
  6. Would you rather have a present or a homemade Christmas card?
  7. Would you rather spend a day watching Christmas videos or spend a day Christmas shopping at the mall?
  8. Would you rather have a Christmas ham or a turkey?
  9. Would you rather have a Christmas tree that was already cut down and decorated or cut down and decorate it yourself?
Would You Rather Holiday Question: Would you rather have a Christmas tree that was already cut down and decorated or cut down and decorate it yourself? on a red background
  1. Would you rather eat Christmas cookies for 6 months or candy canes for 6 months?
  2. Would you rather work at the mall on Christmas Eve or the day after Christmas?
  3. Would you rather give a gift or receive a gift?
  4. Would you rather be Mrs. Claus or the head elf in Santa’s workshop?
  5. Would you rather have a real Christmas tree or a reusable one?
  6. Would you rather have a gingerbread house or a gingerbread man?
  7. Would you rather live at the North Pole or the South Pole?
  8. Would you rather write a letter to Santa or send him an email?
  9. Would you rather have a walk in the snow or drive in the snow?
  10. Would you rather go for a ride in Santa’s sleigh or take a trip on the Polar Express?
Would You Rather Holiday Question: Would you rather go for a ride in Santa’s sleigh or take a trip on the Polar Express? on a green background
  1. Would you rather do Secret Santa or receive a gift card?
  2. Would you rather have egg nog or hot cocoa?
  3. Would you rather eat Christmas dinner at home or help serve Christmas dinner to those who are less fortunate?
  4. Would you rather watch the Santa parade or the Christmas parade?
  5. Would you rather eat Thanksgiving food every day or never again?
  6. Would you rather Santa’s red suit to school or wear a green elf suit to school?
  7. Would you rather have your family home for Christmas or away for a week of vacation?
  8. Would you rather have a Christmas dinner or a Christmas lunch?
  9. Would you rather eat cookies or candy canes?
  10. Would you rather be one of Santa’s reindeer or be one of Santa’s elves?
Would You Rather Holiday Question: Would you rather be one of Santa’s reindeer or be one of Santa’s elves? on a green background
  1. Would you rather give up Christmas trees or Christmas cookies?
  2. Would you rather have Christmas Eve at your house or someone else’s house?
  3. Would you rather work in Santa’s workshop or work in a giant toy store?
  4. Would you rather shovel the snow in the driveway or mow the lawn?
  5. Would you rather listen to Christmas songs on the radio or watch Christmas movies on television?
  6. Would you rather have a snow day or get double pay?
  7. Would you rather have a snowy Christmas or a hot Christmas, with no snow at all?
  8. Would you rather have a white Christmas or a green Christmas?
  9. Would you rather have have sunshine on Christmas or 3 feet of snow?
  10. Would you rather lose your voice for the holidays or only be able to speak in Christmas carols?
Would You Rather Holiday Question: Would you rather lose your voice for the holidays or only be able to speak in Christmas carols? on a green background
  1. Would you rather have the smell of pine needles or the smell of cinnamon?
  2. Would you rather drink peppermint tea or drink cinnamon tea?
  3. Would you rather be best friends with Frosty the Snowmanor Rudolph the red nosed reindeer?
  4. Would you rather sing carols during the holidays or read your favorite book on vacation?
  5. Would you rather receive one big gift worth $1000 or 100 smaller gifts worth $1000?
  6. Would you rather only be allowed to listen to Christmas carols for a year or have to make toys for a year?
  7. Would you rather eat Christmas cookies or gingerbread cookies?
  8. Would you rather do all the Christmas shopping or do all the Christmas cooking?
  9. Would you rather drink only eggnog all December or eat candy canes all December?
  10. Would you rather have snow for Christmas or lots of sunshine for Christmas?
Would You Rather Holiday Question: Would you rather have snow for Christmas or lots of sunshine for Christmas? on a red background
  1. Would you rather listen to Jingle Bells on repeat or Frosty the Snowman?
  2. Would you rather have a red nose that lights upor have pointy elf ears?
  3. Would you rather watch The Grinch movie or Elf movie?
  4. Would you rather wear an ugly Christmas sweater or matching Christmas PJs?
  5. Would you rather Christmas caroling or go sledding?
  6. Would you rather get a Christmas present or the money to buy your own gifts?
  7. Would you rather have an artificial Christmas tree or a real Christmas tree?
  8. Would you rather be a mouse and receive a BIG piece of cheese for Christmas or be a cat and receive a BIG fish for Christmas?
  9. Would you rather have to loudly sing the chorus of “Jingle Bells” every time you walk into a room for a week or have to wear a Santa suit to school every day for a week?
  10. Would you rather be a melting snowman or a munched on gingerbread person?
Would You Rather Holiday Question: Would you rather be a melting snowman or a munched on gingerbread person? on a red background
  1. Would you rather go sledding or make a snow angel?
  2. Would you rather make presents for your family instead of buying them or make ornaments for your Christmas tree instead of buying them?
  3. Would you rather make toys all year longer play with toys all year long?
  4. Would you rather decorate a Christmas tree or decorate Christmas cookies?
  5. Would you rather not celebrate Christmas this year or not celebrate your birthday this year?
  6. Would you rather be Rudolph the red-nosed reindeer or Prancer, or Dancer, or Blitzen?
  7. Would you rather have Frosty the Snowman for a friend or Rudolf the Red-Nosed Reindeer for a friend?
  8. Would you rather spend a day with Mrs. Claus or Santa Claus?
  9. Would you rather have mistletoe hanging in your bedroom doorway or have a large, decorated Christmas tree in your bedroom doorway?
  10. Would you rather chug a gallon of eggnog or a gallon of hot chocolate?
Would You Rather Holiday Question:Would you rather chug a gallon of eggnog or a gallon of hot chocolate? on a green background
  1. Would you rather eat Christmas cookies with Santa or bake Christmas cookies with Mrs. Claus?
  2. Would you rather snuggle up next to a fireplace or layout on the beach?
  3. Would you rather have a Christmas tree tinsel for hair or have fingernails that light up like Christmas lights?
  4. Would you rather eat a gingerbread house or live in a gingerbread house?
  5. Would you rather see the Nutcracker or dance in The Nutcracker?
  6. Would you rather drive Santa’s sleigh or ride along next to him?
  7. Would you rather have a belly that shakes like a bowl full of jelly or eats a bowl full of jelly?
  8. Would you rather be at home on Christmas and get lots of presents or go to Disneyland for Christmas but not get any presents?
  9. Would you rather go ice skating or skiing?
  10. Would you rather get coal in your stocking or nothing in your stocking?
Would You Rather Holiday Question: Would you rather get coal in your stocking or nothing in your stocking? on a green background
  1. Would you rather eat your cereal with eggnog instead of milk or eat a candy cane sandwich?
  2. Would you rather watch the Christmas movie, Elf or the Grinch?
  3. Would you rather live in a giant gingerbread house or ride on the Polar Express?
  4. Would you rather have a red nose like Rudolf or a black button nose like Frosty?
  5. Would you rather be allowed to only eat fruitcake for two days or be allowed to only eat candy canes for two days?
  6. Would you rather eat an entire gingerbread house or a bag of marshmallows?
  7. Would you rather write a five-paragraph essay about the meaning of Christmas or solve a page of Christmas-themed math problems?
  8. Would you rather listen to Christmas carolers or go caroling?
  9. Would you rather have a nose that glows red like Rudolf’s or have pointy ears like an elf?
  10. Would you rather smell like a pine tree or smell like a cinnamon stick?
Would You Rather Holiday Question: Would you rather smell like a pine tree or smell like a cinnamon stick? on a green background
  1. Would you rather visit the North Pole or visit Bethlehem?
  2. Would you rather decorate your house in colorful lights or decorate your house in white lights?
  3. Would you rather receive socks for Christmas or receive a dictionary for Christmas?
  4. Would you rather meet Frosty the Snowman or Elf on the Shelf?
  5. Would you rather be given $100 for Christmas to buy things for yourself or be given $1000 before Christmas to use to buy gifts for other people?
  6. Would you rather spend all day watching Christmas movies or spend all day listening to Christmas music?
  7. Would you rather get many small presents for Christmas or get one big present for Christmas?
  8. Would you rather have tinsel for hair or reindeer legs?
  9. Would you rather have a job wrapping presents at the mall or have a job taking pictures of children sitting on Santa’s lap at the mall?
  10. Would you rather smell like a pine tree or look like a ginger man/woman?
Would You Rather Holiday Question: Would you rather smell like a pine tree or look like a ginger man/woman? on a red background

Which Would you rather holiday questions would you add to the list? Share in the comments so we can add them!

Love Would You Rather? Try These fun Versions!

 
Get Access to Hundreds of 
Free Printables!
Sign up for free and become a Confessions of Parenting VIP and grab all our free printables!
Great! Now Check your email to confirm your subscription and gain instant access with the link in your email!

How Do I access my free printables?

Fill in the form above. You will receive an email in your inbox. If you don’t see it, check your spam folder! You will then click to confirm your subscription. Once confirmed, you will be taken to Airtable (a different website) where all our free printables will be waiting for you! It is free to sign up for Air Table!

How Do I Print a PDF?

You’ll need a program that supports PDFs. Adobe Acrobat is a great option. Open the program, click File, then print. Select your printer and the number of copies you want to print. Be sure you click double-sided if you want it to print on both sides.

Can I resell these?

You may not resell any printable found on our website or in our resource library. You may use them for class parties, at church, at home, or in the classroom. You may get these printed at an office supply store or copy center at your own expense.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.