100+ Scary Would You Rather Questions You’ll Love

Last Updated on March 11, 2022 by Michele Tripple

This post contains affiliate links. If you click and buy we may make a commission, at no additional charge to you. Please see our disclosure for more details.

These 100+ scary would you rather questions are thrilling, spooky, and definitely fun! Perfect for Halloween, scary movie night, or anything in between, these would you rather scary questions are just what you need and make the best conversation starters.

Scary Would You Rather Questions

Put the little ones to bed and give these scary would you rather questions a try! It’s the classic which-one game with a spooky twist.

featured image: scar would you rather in a gray background

Who doesn’t love a good game of Would You Rather? We love playing would you rather for teens, kids would you rather is just as much fun for me as it is for my kids! But sometimes, you need something a little more adult, and these would you rather scary questions are perfect for those times.

You could use these spooky questions all year long at scary movie nights, around the campfire, or any other time. They’re especially fun to use in the fall alongside my Halloween Would You Rather Questions!

As long as you’re ready for a little fright, these would you rather questions are just what you need.

Benefits of Would You Rather Questions

Would you rather questions are so much fun, but they can also be really beneficial in other ways.

And with these would you rather scary questions, you never know what you’ll find out about someone!

How to Play Would You Rather Scary Version

Using these scary would you rather questions is so simple. All you need to do is scroll down to download the printable question cards, or you can look right on this page at the list of questions.

Once your questions are ready, it’s as easy as reading the question and answering it! There are no winners or losers, just plenty of laughs! Depending on the size of your group, there are a few ways that you can play.

If you are playing with two people, take turns reading the questions to each other. If you have a group or family, you have each person answer one question, or you can all answer them as a group and compare answers.

With a big group like a class or a party, you can have people stand on one side of the room if they answer one way, and the other side if they answer the other. Just don’t be surprised if a debate breaks out!

Tools that make Scary Would You Rather Questions Even Easier

  • Use a timer! When people are indecisive it helps to use a timer to help them decide faster. Make sure you use a visual timer if you are playing with kids!
  • Try using whiteboards if you are playing in a group and everyone can write their answer down and reveal it at the same time. My family loves playing this way!

How to Download Your Free Scary Would You Rather Questions

To get your free download of these scary would you rather questions, fill out the form below to become a VIP member of Confessions of Parenting. Or if you aren’t ready to join in on all the fun yet, head over to our store to grab the questions right now!

100+ Scary Would You Rather Questions

pin image: scary would you rather with a ghosts

Here’s your 100+ scary would you rather questions! Be sure to let us know in the comment which is your favorite!

  1. Would you rather pull your own thumbnail off with a fork or put a toothpick under your big toe and kick a wall?
scary would you rather question: Would you rather pull your own thumbnail off with a fork or put a toothpick under your big toe and kick a wall? on a gray background
  1. Would you rather be haunted by a ghost, or be a ghost?
  2. Would you rather marry into the Addams family or cut off your own ring finger?
  3. Would you rather be attacked by crows or bats?
  4. Would you rather brutally murder six strangers, or be part of the human centipede?
  5. Would you rather spend an entire night in a coffin underground or spend a night in a haunted hotel?
  6. Would you rather walk through a graveyard at midnight or spend a night in a spooky abandoned old house?
  7. Would you rather live in the house from The Haunting of Hill House or American Horror Story: Murder House?
  8. Would you rather be cursed to live forever or to die young?
  9. Would you rather dunk for apples or carve a jack-lantern?
scary would you rather question: Would you rather dunk for apples or carve a jack-lantern? on a gray background
  1. Would you rather piss of Maleficent or the Wicked Witch of the West?
  2. Would you rather get a surprise visit from Frankenstein’s monster or a surprise visit from The Headless Horseman?
  3. Would you rather fight Dracula, Frankenstein or the Wolf Man?
  4. Would you rather go to a real haunted house or watch a horror movie marathon?
  5. Would you rather put your hand into a dark slimy hole to try and find something small, or walk into a very spooky dark cave to try and find something big?
  6. Would you rather visit a cemetery or visit a pet cemetery at midnight?
  7. Would you rather have coffee come out of your nose every time you sneeze or have bacon for nails?
  8. Would you rather watch a scary movie with a scary movie buff or watch a scary movie with a scaredy-cat?
  9. Would you rather be chased by Freddy Krueger, Jason Vorhees, Michael Myers, or Ghostface?
  10. Would you rather be absolutely terrified of the dark or be afraid of the thing underneath your bed?
  1. Would you rather be eaten alive by rats or by fish?
  2. Would you rather live in a cemetery or haunted house?
  3. Would you rather have a friendly but scary-looking monster under your bed for the rest of your life or have nightmares every day for the rest of your life?
  4. Would you rather get a foot massage from the monster under your bed or dance the tango with the monster in your closet?
  5. Would you rather only watch romantic comedies for the rest of your life or only watch horror movies for the rest of your life?
  6. Which would you rather have double in size, your hands or feet?
  7. Would you rather be killed by a vampire or get turned into a vampire?
  8. Would you rather be a werewolf or vampire?
  9. Would you rather get kidnapped by a psychopath or get abducted by aliens?
  10. Would you rather be chased by one werewolf or ten zombies?
scary would you rather question: Would you rather be chased by one werewolf or ten zombies? on a green background
  1. Would you rather live as a ghost on earth after you die or just stay dead?
  2. Would you rather fight a giant basilisk or a giant spider?
  3. Would you rather die from a shark attack or die from a zombie attack?
  4. Would you rather deal with Annabelle or with Chucky?
  5. Would you rather save your mom and let 100 innocent people die or save 100 innocent people and let your mom die?
  6. Would you rather eat a spider or a slug?
  7. Would you rather have dinner with Hannibal Lecter or with Patrick Bateman?
  8. Would you rather drink a gallon of mayonnaise or a gallon of ketchup?
  9. Would you rather have visual hallucinations of “The Ring” girl or Freddy Krueger from “A Nightmare on Elm Street”?
  10. Would you rather eat your cereal with water as milk or lemon juice?
scary would you rather question: Would you rather eat your cereal with water as milk or lemon juice? on a brown background
  1. Would you rather spend a night at Bates Motel or spend a night in room 1408?
  2. Would you rather get attacked by a skeleton or a ghost?
  3. Would you rather say “Bloody Marry” three times in front of the mirror or read the book from “The Babadook”?
  4. Would you rather forever be chased by Pennywise or forever run away from the creature from “It Follows”?
  5. Would you rather live in an active volcano or inside a big tree?
  6. Would you rather have the old lady Mrs. Sylvia Ganush from the movie “Drag Me to Hell” as your grandmother or have Rosemary’s baby from the movie “Rosemary’s Baby”?
  7. Would you rather get frightened by someone, or give someone else a fright?
  8. Would you rather be super itchy all over forever or be really sticky all over forever?
  9. Would you rather move into the house from the movie “Paranormal Activity” or the house of the movie “Insidious”?
  10. Would you rather give birth to an elephant or to a dog?
scary would you rather question: Would you rather give birth to an elephant or to a dog? on a green background
  1. Would you rather let a tarantula crawl up your arm or a snake wrap around your neck?
  2. Would you rather have a head the size of a tennis ball or the size of a watermelon?
  3. Would you rather be stuck on “Shutter Island” or be stuck in the mental institution “Briarcliff” from the TV-Show “American Horror Story” (Season: 2 “Asylum”)?
  4. Would you rather wake up in the middle of the night to Chucky or Pennywise?
  5. Would you rather have all your shoes filled with spaghetti or have all your socks be wet all the time?
  6. Would you rather have a toad as a best friend or have a black cat as an enemy?
  7. Would you rather have a new “Saw” movie or a new “Scream” movie?
  8. Would you rather have the best house in a scary neighborhood or the worst house in a fancy neighborhood?
  9. Would you rather have shark gills or a giraffe’s neck?
  10. Would you rather be lost in the woods with a killer on the loose or locked in a haunted insane asylum?
scary would you rather question: Would you rather be lost in the woods with a killer on the loose or locked in a haunted insane asylum? on a gray background
  1. Would you rather wake up in a glass coffin that slowly fills up with water or wake up in a locked room that is on fire?
  2. Would you rather scream like a banshee every time you try to talk, or have snakes for hair?
  3. Would you rather be trapped in a cave of bats or stuck in a pit of spiders?
  4. Would you rather be the first or the last who turns into a zombie in a zombie apocalypse?
  5. Would you rather eat a talking cow or a talking chicken?
  6. Would you rather be one of the survivors in “28 Days Later” or “Zombieland”?
  7. Would you rather be possessed by a demon or find out that all your family members are possessed by demons?
  8. Would you rather have pins growing out of your face and head, or have scissors where your fingers should be?
  9. Would you rather peel all your nails out of your fingers or pull all the teeth out of your mouth?
  10. Would you rather accidentally bite off the tip of your tongue or accidentally rip off your small finger?
scary would you rather question: Would you rather accidentally bite off the tip of your tongue or accidentally rip off your small finger? on a gray background
  1. Would you rather eat dog food with sugar, or eat snails with garlic butter?
  2. Would you rather be an alien or an animal?
  3. Would you rather freeze to death or burn to death?
  4. Would you rather drown or burn to death?
  5. Would you rather eat a sugared spider or eat a fried snake?
  6. Would you rather have a long and painful death in your 80’s or a quick and sudden one in your 40’s?
  7. Would you rather have no arms or no legs?
  8. Would you rather know when you die or how you die?
  9. Would you rather have no fingers or no eyes?
  10. Would you rather have Freddy Krueger or Michael Myers stalk you?
scary would you rather question: WWould you rather have Freddy Krueger or Michael Myers stalk you? on a blue background
  1. Would you rather have knives for fingers or snakes for fingers?
  2. Would you rather have no legs or no fingers?
  3. Would you rather have a witch’s green skin or a werewolf’s hairy fur all over your face and body?
  4. Would you rather live forever or die in the next five minutes?
  5. Would you rather lose your arms or your legs?
  6. Would you rather summon dark forces using black candles and Latin phrases, or eat a ghost pepper (no drinks allowed)?
  7. Would you rather lose your sense of smell or touch?
  8. Would you rather eat a caterpillar sandwich or let spiders crawl on your face?
  9. Would you rather trick or treat in a creative costume or a scary costume?
  10. Would you rather be able to see ghosts or talk to them?
scary would you rather question: Would you rather be able to see ghosts or talk to them? on a brown background
  1. Would you rather watch a horror film or visit the dentist?
  2. Would you rather go skydiving or bungee jumping?
  3. Would you rather be best friends with Wednesday Addams or Sabrina the Teenage witch?
  4. When you were a kid, would you rather know if Santa Claus was real or the ghosts under your bed/in your closet?
  5. Would you rather look like a zombie or smell like a zombie?
  6. Would you rather jump off the Eiffel Tower or into a volcano?
  7. Would you rather have a time machine that only goes back in time or a time machine that only goes forward in time?
  8. Would you rather have faux fur as skin or have leaves for hair?
  9. Would you rather be stuck in “It” or “It Follows”?
  10. Would you rather have to sleep hanging upside down or sleep in a coffin?
scary would you rather question: Would you rather have to sleep hanging upside down or sleep in a coffin? on a green background

Love Would You Rather? Try These fun Versions!

 
Get Access to Hundreds of 
Free Printables!
Sign up for free and become a Confessions of Parenting VIP and grab all our free printables!
Great! Now Check your email to confirm your subscription and gain instant access with the link in your email!

How Do I access my free printables?

Fill in the form above. You will receive an email in your inbox. If you don’t see it check your spam folder! You will then click to confirm your subscription. Once confirmed you will be taken to Airtable (a different website) where all our free printables will be waiting for you! It is free to sign up for Air Table!

How Do I Print a PDF?

You’ll need a program that supports PDFs. Adobe Acrobat is a great option. Open the program, click file then print. Select your printer and the number of copies you want to print. Be sure you click double-sided if you want it to print on both sides.

Can I resell these?

You may not resell any printable that you find on our website or in our resource library. You may use them for class parties, at church, at home, or in the classroom. You may get these printed at an office supply store or copy center at your own expense.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.