200 Best Christmas Would You Rather Questions

This post contains affiliate links. If you click and buy we may make a commission, at no additional charge to you. Please see our disclosure for more details.

Start a new tradition with your family this year and get into the Christmas spirit with these festive Christmas Would You Rather questions! Just download, print, and play!

Examples of the Christmas Would You Rather printables with a red border.

Would You Rather Christmas

With presents, food, sweets, decorations, and family time, Christmas is my favorite time of year! I am always on the hunt for some fun games that the whole family can play. My kids can’t get enough of Christmas Charades so to keep the holiday fun going, I’ve created Christmas Would You Rather questions!

2 elves and candy canes with a string of Christmas lights on green background with white words with red outline that says Christmas would you rather

Would You Rather is such a fun and simple game to play as a family. I love Christmas Would You Rather because it gets everyone talking about the holidays and it’s easy for everyone to play, no matter the age!

So when you are brainstorming Christmas Party Ideas, make sure to include a round of Would You Rather Christmas edition!

Three examples of the would you rather game on a bright green background with the texting stating it is perfect for families, classroom parties, and Christmas gatherings!

How to Play Christmas Would You Rather

Christmas Would You Rather is such an easy and simple game to play. You just need to scroll down to see the questions or download our Would You Rather Christmas Edition and ask away!

Would you rather Christmas edition is customizable to however you want to play it. You just need to take turns asking questions. You can answer each question or you can give each person a different question. The best part of the game is hearing everyone’s answers!

There are no winners or losers in this game so everyone can have a good time playing. That means no stress, just lots of fun!

If you’re looking to get the conversation started this Christmas and laugh together as a family, Christmas Would You Rather is the perfect game!

Five examples of the would you rather Christmas questions on a red background.

Tips and Tricks

Add the element of surprise! Grab some whiteboards and have everyone answer the same question. Then count to three and have everyone reveal their answers at once. It’s so fun to be surprised together!

To switch things up you can try to guess what the person next to you would choose. It’s a great way to make things more challenging and see how well you know each other!

Christmas Would You Rather

Christmas Would You Rather Questions for Kids
Christmas Would You Rather for Teens
Christmas Would You Rather for the Whole Family

Gear up for the Holidays with this Mega Christmas Game Collection!

Example of the Christmas would you rather printable with testimonials of the printable with a green border with text stating over 100 questions perfect for the whole family, easy to print, and great for parties and classrooms.

Christmas Would You Rather Questions for Kids

Would you rather go on Santa’s sleigh or help the elves make toys?
Would you rather decorate the Christmas tree or wrap presents?
Would you rather wear ugly Christmas sweaters or jingle bell shoes for the whole season?
Would you rather get a huge, impractical gift or a tiny, super-useful gift?
Would you rather be able to instantly decorate your house for Christmas or instantly clean up after New Year’s?

Would you rather have a Christmas tree that decorates itself or gifts that wrap themselves?
Would you rather watch only Christmas movies or listen only to Christmas music for a month?
Would you rather get one big present or lots of small presents?
Would you rather be able to make snow at will or make holiday treats appear whenever you want?
Would you rather have a white Christmas every year or go shop for presents in shorts and flip-flops?

Would you rather have a Christmas tree with just lights or just ornaments?
Would you rather get a lump of coal that turns into a diamond after 5 years or a regular gift?
Would you rather have Christmas crackers or Christmas pudding?
Would you rather have a sleigh ride with Santa or a magic carpet ride with Aladdin?
Would you rather eat a turkey leg or a mountain of mashed potatoes?

Would you rather have a Christmas piñata or a Christmas scavenger hunt?
Would you rather write letters to Santa or emails to the elves?
Would you rather live in a gingerbread house or a palace made of snow?
Would you rather never eat another candy cane or never sing a Christmas carol again?
Would you rather have an everlasting snow globe or a magical Christmas ornament?

Would you rather have to whisper or sing everything you say on Christmas Day?
Would you rather visit the toy workshop or the reindeer stables?
Would you rather make snow angels or snow forts?
Would you rather always win at Christmas trivia or be unbeatable at Christmas board games?
Would you rather spend Christmas Eve with the characters from “Home Alone” or “Elf”?

Would you rather have a Christmas advent calendar filled with toys or filled with treats?
Would you rather have a Christmas tree so big it touches the ceiling or one that’s small but full of memories?
Would you rather wear a Santa suit or an elf outfit for a day?
Would you rather get gifts only from your wish list or be totally surprised?
Would you rather have twinkling Christmas lights that play music or ones that change colors?

Would you rather have stockings full of toys or full of candy?
Would you rather unwrap a gift very slowly or rip it open super fast?
Would you rather spend Christmas with Frosty the Snowman or Olaf from “Frozen”?
Would you rather have a snowball fight or go sledding?
Would you rather have hot cocoa with marshmallows or apple cider?

Would you rather open a present every day for a month or all at once on Christmas day?
Would you rather give presents to everyone and get none, or get presents from everyone and give none?
Would you rather build a snowman or an igloo?
Would you rather eat Christmas dinner with the Grinch or Scrooge?
Would you rather go caroling door-to-door or have a Christmas movie marathon?

Would you rather stay up late on Christmas Eve or wake up super early on Christmas Day?
Would you rather have a red nose like Rudolph or pointed ears like an elf?
Would you rather eat a Christmas feast for breakfast or have Christmas cookies for dinner?
Would you rather be a star on top of the Christmas tree or a snowflake in a winter storm?
Would you rather have a pet reindeer or a pet penguin?

Would you rather find an elf hiding in your house or catch Santa delivering presents?
Would you rather celebrate Christmas in the North Pole or on a tropical island?
Would you rather sing carols with the Chipmunks or dance with the Sugar Plum Fairy?
Would you rather have a snowball fight with Frosty the Snowman or build a sandcastle with Rudolph?
Would you rather eat only candy canes or only gingerbread cookies for a week?

Christmas Would You Rather for Teens

Would you rather spend Christmas vacation snowboarding or relaxing on a beach?
Would you rather go viral for an embarrassing Christmas party moment or not go to the party at all?
Would you rather get unlimited Spotify Premium or Netflix for a year?
Would you rather spend Christmas Day playing video games or binge-watching your favorite series?
Would you rather get a brand-new phone or a brand-new laptop for Christmas?

Would you rather be stuck at a Christmas family gathering with no Wi-Fi or no food?
Would you rather re-gift something or give a super weird homemade gift?
Would you rather take an epic Christmas selfie with a celeb or with Santa Claus?
Would you rather Snapchat your entire Christmas Day or totally unplug?
Would you rather listen to Christmas rap or heavy metal Christmas songs?

Would you rather be famous on TikTok for a hilarious Christmas fail or a Christmas miracle?
Would you rather have to post only Christmas puns or corny Christmas jokes on your social media for a month?
Would you rather go Christmas shopping in person on Black Friday or wait until the last minute and only shop online?
Would you rather spend Christmas at Hogwarts or in the Star Wars galaxy?
Would you rather have your text messages read aloud at a family gathering or your search history?

Would you rather be stuck wearing a Christmas onesie or Christmas pajamas for a week?
Would you rather watch “Christmas Vacation” or “Elf” on repeat for 24 hours?
Would you rather help your parents cook Christmas dinner or do the dishes afterward?
Would you rather get one big-ticket item or lots of small, thoughtful gifts?
Would you rather carol in your neighborhood or just watch carolers from the comfort of your home?

Would you rather give up Christmas cookies or Christmas presents?
Would you rather get caught re-gifting or giving a clearly last-minute gift you bought on clearance with the tag still on?
Would you rather experience Christmas in a virtual reality world or go on an actual adventure?
Would you rather host a low-key Christmas party with a few friends or a big bash with everyone you know?
Would you rather wear Christmas-themed AirPods or have a Christmas-themed phone case?

Would you rather spend the holidays with your friends or with your extended family?
Would you rather go to a Christmas music festival or have a cozy movie night at home?
Would you rather be the Secret Santa or the one who guesses who everyone’s Secret Santa is?
Would you rather be gifted concert tickets or a new game console?
Would you rather have traditional Christmas lights or neon Christmas lights in your room?

Would you rather live in a world where it’s Christmas every day or where Christmas never happens?
Would you rather have an ugly Christmas sweater party or a fancy Christmas Eve gala?
Would you rather spend Christmas in a haunted house or in the middle of a desert?
Would you rather go to a Christmas party where you know nobody or not go to any parties at all?
Would you rather get a Christmas tattoo or have Christmas-themed hair for a month?

Would you rather work retail during the Christmas season or be a mall Santa’s helper?
Would you rather have the ability to instantly wrap gifts or instantly untangle Christmas lights?
Would you rather celebrate Christmas in the past or in a futuristic world?
Would you rather have Christmas dinner at a fancy restaurant or homemade with all the family faves?
Would you rather stay up all night on Christmas Eve or sleep in on Christmas Day?

Would you rather only be able to buy gifts from a thrift shop or from a luxury store?
Would you rather eat fruitcake or boiled Brussels sprouts for every meal for a week?
Would you rather have your Christmas playlist chosen by your parents or by your youngest sibling?
Would you rather be visited by Christmas ghosts (think the “A Christmas Carol”) or abducted by Christmas aliens?
Would you rather be super skilled at ice skating or making hot cocoa?

Would you rather listen to your grandparents’ Christmas stories for the 100th time or attend a boring Christmas lecture on saving money?
Would you rather have Christmas without snow or without presents?
Would you rather create a viral Christmas meme or star in a popular Christmas YouTube video?
Would you rather spend Christmas in a big city with all the lights and buzz or in a quiet, snowy village?

Christmas Would You Rather Questions for the Whole Family

Red nose reindeer with a green scarf and a would you rather questions with a green border.

Have a pumpkin pie fight or an apple pie fight with friends?
Relive a past winter holiday again or get to travel to a future winter holiday?
Have elf ears or a Santa beard?
Spend the holidays with your family or with three of your favorite celebrities?

Santa Claus holding bright yellow and red presents with a would you rather questions with a green border.

Have Rudolph follow you around every day until Christmas or be followed by Frosty the Snowman?
Cook the big Christmas meal every year or have to clean up and do the dishes after the Christmas meal every year?
Wrap Christmas presents for 8 hours or help children take pictures with Santa at the Mall?
Be a kid or a grandparent during the holidays?
Give up one family holiday tradition or start a new one?

An elf in a red and green suit with a Christmas would you rather questions with a green border.

Have 7 hours of Christmas shopping or 10 hours of Christmas movies?
Have a red Rudolph Nose or a Frosty button nose?
Invent a holiday on whatever day you want or have a holiday fall on your birthday?
Ask everyone you meet their favorite color or their favorite food?
Eat Thanksgiving or Christmas food every day?

A tree with snow on the branches with a bright yellow star on top with a would you rather question with a green border.

Watch Elf or It’s a Wonderful Life?
Work in Santa’s workshop or work in a giant toy store?
Make snow angels or go ice skating?
Go for a ride in Santa’s sleigh or take a trip on the Polar Express?
Live in a giant gingerbread house or in Santa’s toy shop?

A gingerbread house with bright colored candies and a red door with a question with a green border.

Decorate 100 Christmas trees or decorate 100 Christmas cookies?
Have 7 levels of the candy cane forest or sea of swirly whirly gumdrops?
Have a snowy Christmas or a hot Christmas?
Eat only fruitcake for a week or drink only eggnog for a week?
Lose your voice for the holidays Or only be able to speak in Christmas carols?

Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer with a green polka dot scarf and red saddle blanket with a would you rather question with a green border.

Be the Grinch or Cindy Lou Who?
Wear Santa’s red suit to school or wear a green elf suit to school?
Have candy cane for legs or gumdrops for eyes?
Eat Christmas dinner at home or help serve Christmas dinner to those who are less fortunate?
Have large ornaments for earrings or a decorated wreath necklace?

A red striped north pole sign with snow on it with a Christmas would you rather question and a green border.

Have a red nose that lights up or have pointy elf ears?
Only be allowed to listen to Christmas carols for a year or have to make toys for a year?
Sing Jingle Bells once every hour for 2 weeks or wear an Elf costume to school for 1 week?
Be best friends with Frosty the Snowman or Rudolph the red-nosed reindeer?
Watch How the Grinch Stole Christmas or the Christmas Story?

Receive one big present or receive 10 small presents?
Wear a hat made of mistletoe or wear jingle bells on your feet for a week?
Open your presents on Christmas Eve or on Christmas morning?
Have mittens for hands or skis for feet?
Eat Christmas cookies for 6 months or eat candy canes for 6 months?

Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer pulling Santa Claus in his Red sleigh full of presents with questions and a green border.

Never receive another gift from anyone ever again or be forced to give everyone in your family an adult toy as a gift?
Have your elf on a shelf talk to you or talk with your Christmas tree?
Fly like a reindeer or roll like a snowman?
Have to loudly sing the chorus of Jingle Bells every time you walk into a room for a week or wear a Santa suit to school every day for a week?
Go home with family for the Holidays or Disneyworld by yourself?

Make presents for your family instead of buying them or make ornaments for your Christmas tree instead of buying them?
Sing Christmas carols by yourself or sit on Santa’s lap for 1 hour?
Not celebrate Christmas this year or not celebrate your birthday this year?
Rake leaves or shovel snow?
Be a mouse and receive a BIG piece of cheese for Christmas or be a cat and receive a BIG fish for Christmas?

Snowed in with complete family during the holidays or on a beach with just a few of your family members?
Have a mistletoe hanging in your bedroom or have a large decorated Christmas tree in your bedroom?
Be in a scene from Home Alone or Elf?
Eat your cereal with eggnog instead of milk or eat a candy cane sandwich?
Grow a permanent Santa beard or grow permanent reindeer antlers?

Be an elf at the North Pole or one of Santa’s reindeer?
Be allowed to only eat fruitcake for two days or be allowed to only eat candy canes for two days?
Work as a mall Santa for the rest of your life or become the real Santa and have to live in the North Pole?
Have eyes made out of coal or reindeer feet?
Drink only eggnog all December or eat candy canes all December?

Have a snowball for a head or 100 jingle bells for hair?
Have the Elf on the Shelf be alive or have Santa actually in your bedroom watching you sleep at night?
Christmas caroling or going sledding?
Spend 11 hours untangling Christmas lights or find the one light that is out on a string of Christmas lights a mile long?
Have turkey for Christmas dinner or have a ham for Christmas dinner?

Have bonfire and smores or holiday videos and hot chocolate?
Wear Santa’s big boots to gym class or wear pointy elf shoes to gym class?
Play in the Super Bowl or perform in the Nutcracker?
Visit the north pole or visit Bethlehem?
Be Rudolph the red-nosed reindeer or Prancer, or Dancer, or Blitzen?

Go sledding or take a horse-drawn sleigh ride?
Have a partridge in a pear tree or 2 turtle doves?
Have 3 French hens or 4 calling birds?
Have 5 golden rings or 6 geese a-laying?
Have 7 swans a swimming or 8 maids a milking?

Have 9 ladies dancing or 10 lords a leaping?
Have 11 pipers piping or 12 drummers drumming?
Spend a day with Mrs. Claus or Santa Claus?
Be an angel on top of the tree or a Jack in the Box toy?
Be Mrs. Claus or be the Head Elf in Santa’s workshop?

Wrap 100 presents or decorate 100 trees?
Spend a day with the Grinch or Jack Frost?
Live at the North Pole or live at the South Pole?
Be a melting snowman or a munched on gingerbread person?
Be on the naughty or nice list?

Eat Christmas cookies with Santa or bake Christmas cookies with Santa?
Have snowflakes for eyelashes or icicles for teeth?
Receive socks for Christmas or receive a dictionary for Christmas?
Have a job wrapping presents at the mall or have a job taking pictures of children sitting on Santa’s lap at the mall?
Have holly for hair or wear Christmas stockings for legs?

Be given $100 for Christmas to buy things for yourself or be given $1000 before Christmas to use to buy gifts for other people?
See the Nut Cracker or dance in the Nut Cracker?
Have strings of cranberries for fingers or figgy pudding toes?
Spend a day watching Christmas videos or spend a day Christmas shopping at the mall?
Wear ugly Christmas sweaters for 1 year or stay with the abominable snowman for 1 week?

Have Christmas tree tinsel for hair or have fingernails that light up like Christmas lights?
Take a look at Santa’s list or peek at your presents?
Live in a giant gingerbread house or ride on the Polar Express?
Laugh like Santa or talk like an elf?
Write a five-paragraph essay about the meaning of Christmas or solve a page of Christmas-themed math problems?
String a mile of popcorn garland or light and keep 500 candles burning at once?

Listen to music with headphones or listen to music from a speaker?
Grow Santa’s beard or Santa’s belly?
Meet the Grinch or Be the Grinch?
Wear matching ugly sweaters with your family or matching PJs?

What Christmas Would you Rather Questions would you add? Share in the comments!

If you love, would you rather, grab some of our most popular would you rather games!

Ready for More Christmas Games Or Printables? Try these!

How Do I access my free printables?

Fill in the form above. You will receive an email in your inbox. If you don’t see it, check your spam folder! You will then click to confirm your subscription. Once confirmed, you will be sent your printable through your email.

How Do I Print a PDF?

You’ll need a program that supports PDFs. Adobe Acrobat is a great option. Open the program, click File, then print. Select your printer and the number of copies you want to print. Be sure you click double-sided if you want it to print on both sides.

Can I resell these?

You may not resell any printable found on our website or in our resource library. You may use them for class parties, at church, at home, or in the classroom. You may get these printed at an office supply store or copy center at your own expense.

Michele Tripple

Michele Tripple is a renowned author and expert in the fields of parenting, relationships, and personal development. With her degree in marriage and family studies, her experience as a Family Life Educator, and over a decade of experience as a professional writer, Michele has authored books that provide practical advice and insights into improving family dynamics and personal growth. Her work is celebrated for its blend of research-driven information and relatable, real-world applications. Michele has been a keynote speaker at conferences and has contributed to numerous publications and media outlets, solidifying her reputation as an authoritative voice in her field and helping families build relationships.